Hello dear
Welcome To The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza
The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza, located in Indialantic, FL, is a must-visit for pizza enthusiasts seeking an authentic New York experience. Renowned for its crispy thin crust and large, flavorful slices, this pizzeria has garnered rave reviews from patrons who appreciate the quality and taste of its ingredients. Signature dishes like the house pie and fried calamari stand out, inviting diners to savor each bite. The welcoming staff and vibrant indoor-outdoor dining atmosphere enhance the overall experience. If you're in Brevard County and craving true NYC-style pizza, Bizzarro’s is the ultimate destination.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Rice Balls
18 Stuffed Pizza - Meat
Bizzarro Combo
Margherita Pizza 24
About
The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza
Welcome to The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza, where the vibrant essence of New York City pizza meets the laid-back beach vibe of Indialantic, Florida. Nestled at 4 Wave Crest Ave, this eatery is a hidden gem for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic slice of the Big Apple.
As soon as you step inside, the aromas of freshly baked pies greet you, layered with quality ingredients that make your mouth water. The star of the show? The house pie, boasting slices larger than your plate, is a crowd favorite. Diners rave about the crispy thin crust and the perfect balance of flavors. As one customer, Nicholas Lemoine, noted, it offers a “legit pizza” experience that truly embodies the essence of New York.
The menu extends beyond just pizza. Indulge in appetizing selections like the hearty rice balls and mac and cheese bites, or perhaps savor the calamari salad for a lighter option. The Boars Head subs, including the Italian Hero or Capicola & Cheese, provide a fantastic alternative for those in the mood for a sandwich.
What sets The Original Bizzarro apart extends well beyond the food. As evidenced by numerous customer reviews, the staff exudes warmth and friendliness. Whether it’s handling large orders for special events or ensuring dietary accommodations, their commitment to great service is palpable. Melanie C. emphasizes the importance of selecting the house pie and taking a leisurely stroll on the beach afterwards—a perfect combination.
It’s worth noting that this beloved pizzeria operates on a cash-only basis, so be sure to come prepared. The ambiance varies with indoor and outdoor seating, allowing you to enjoy your meal while soaking up the sun or relishing a gentle ocean breeze.
With glowing reviews like “the best pizza in Brevard County” and heartfelt recommendations of “wonderful” service, The Original Bizzarro Famous New York Pizza stands as a must-visit location for pizza lovers. If you’re hunting for a truly classic New York-style pizza experience in Florida, look no further than this delightful spot!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ If your from outta town and want REAL “NYC” ITALIAN Pizza this is your and everyone’s go to. Make sure to order the house pie size to get those slices bigger than your plates. Then take a nice walk on the beach. Indoor/outdoor dinning. ”
“ Legit pizza. Crispy thin crust. A little light on the sauce. Good representation of NY pizza. Large slices, good ingredients, friendly people. A ”
“ Absolutely love this place! Best pizza I’ve had since I’ve lived in Florida. I come from Osceola County just to get their pizza! Just wish the guy at the front counter with the light hair, beard and glasses would smile more, it looks great on him! But in all seriousness if you want great pizza this is the place to go!!! ”
“ Hands down, the best pizza in Brevard County. It features a nice, crisp New York-style crust with flavorful sauce. Don't forget to bring cash, as this restaurant only accepts cash. ”
“ Theses people are WONDERFUL! We ordered 15 pizzas for an after party wedding ceremony and they delivered within 45 minutes of the order being placed and got everything correct! On a Saturday night! In addition sent the bride and groom a little congratulations would recommended over and over again. The pizza was the absolute best we’ve had and they made gluten free accommodations for those who had food allergy! ”
“ Great tasting food and GREAT service. All of the staff were sweet, polite and welcoming. The food came out quick and tasted delicious. I didn't have enough cash, and they gave me my food for the amount I had. I recommend this place tremendously. Location is perfect. Lots of parking and right next to the beach. ”
“ Best pizza & calzone, hands down Everything here is great, place is real chill, and the people are really nice. ”
“ BEST of the BEST all around service, food, atmosphere and Family Friendly full of so much love and hospitality 10/10, A, superb restaurant, highest recommendation possible to Frank and his staff. Original owners of this location since it opened 35 years ago you know it’s the real deal, only cash accepted and the crew works hard for their well earned tips. Italian born, Brooklyn raised, Frank treats all of us like his family and we are so blessed ”